Periodontal Qi
by Dr. Marcy B. Newman, DOM, MPH, RDH
Periodontal diseases are by far the most frequently occurring oral conditions known to man and the leading cause of tooth loss among the American population. In Western dentistry, it has been discovered that multiple periodontal diseases can afflict both adult and juvenile populations, thus the term diseases is used. The dental profession has already found that these diseases occur in over 70% of the United States adult population . From an Oriental medical standpoint, these statistics illustrate an increase of each manifestation categorized within our Chinese periodontal differentiations. According to my research, periodontal disease is classified as: ya xuan = gaping gums, ya lou = leaking gums, and ya nu = bleeding gums.
As quoted by the American Academy of Periodontology, the causes of periodontal diseases are multiple and include:
- Smoking
- Genetics
- Hormonal Fluctuations (pregnancy, puberty, menopause)
- Diabetes
- Stress
- Medications
- Clenching and Grinding of Teeth
- Poor Nutrition
- Other Systemic Diseases
Note that these above factors are usually visible upon inspection of the oral cavity by a dental professional. As a dental hygienist, from an initial glance I can often detect which factor has been influencing my patients. What must be mentioned here is that each patient’s oral hygiene habits and their frequency of dental cleanings play crucial roles in their oral disease status!
Please refer to the periodontal diagram in order to visualize the process and its destruction to the periodontium as the disease progresses. Note the alveolar bone and its fibers that connect it to the cementum or root surface dissolve as the pathogenic process progresses.
From a Western standpoint the periodontal disease process begins with gingivitis or red, puffy gingiva (gums) – as illustrated on the right side of the above illustration—due to the presence of specific bacteria within dental plaque (bacteria, food, and saliva) that adheres to every tooth surface. This biofilm aggravates the tissue by causing an inflammatory response. A professional prophylaxis or cleaning usually performed by a dental hygienist, along with good oral hygiene at home and a plaque-reducing diet (limited carbonated beverages, low carbohydrate intake, and frequent crunchy snacks), can eliminate or minimize this gingivitis sequence of events. However, if the patient does not follow the above recommended treatments, their disease process can progress.
From a Western diagnostics viewpoint, any adult patient ought to receive a periodontal screening at least once per year. The dentist or dental hygienist performs this screening by placing a periodontal probe marked in millimeters in the sulcus, or healthy space, between the gumline and the tooth to record six readings in different locations. The depth of the readings reflect the extent of inflammation or disease present (as a patient, if you hear your dental professional calling out three millimeters or less, you’re in good periodontal health). Aside from periodontal probing, radiographs (x-rays) are essential in diagnosing the bone level and extent of any bone loss that may be present. Unfortunately, as with hypertension, periodontal disease is often painless until its later and more morbid stages.
The patient shown here may not have been aware of any symptoms aside from some increase spacing, slight bleeding upon brushing, and increased tooth size (due to recession of the gingiva). Upon returning to the dentist after several years absence, the hygienist found pockets or increased spaces of 6-7mm between the gingival and teeth and advanced bone loss on the radiographs.
The above radiograph (x-ray) illustrates a dramatic level of bone loss (#B) with a widened periodontal ligament space. This example illustrates advanced periodontal disease due to pathogenic influence as the disease process extends beyond this premolar to the premolar adjacent to it. In normal periodontal health, the bone height ought to be level with the tooth-root margin or Cemento-enamel junction (#A).
Let’s now look at the periodontium and its associated conditions from an Oriental medical perspective.
Chinese Differentiations of Periodontal Disease
In Relation to the Four Heat Levels
- An External contraction of Wind Heat toxins could invade the body and via the Yang Ming channels, they travel northward up into the oral cavity. Both Stomach and Large Intestine meridians are invaded with heat pathogens. The location of the localized sites of pathology helps illustrate which meridian has been affected predominantly. Their heat quality causes redness, bleeding, and all other known signs of inflammation. Your treatment goal as an acupuncturist would be to clear the heat from the upper Yang Ming channel. Choice acupoints would include LI4 and ST45 as well as bleeding these points or the apex of the ear. An herbal formula noted for this purpose would be Chuan Xin Lian (cited for clearing heat, removing toxins and reducing inflammation) or Qi Bao Mei Ran Dan (particularly for advanced periodontal disease with tooth mobility and imbalances in vital energy resulting from progressive Kidney qi and yin decline with the aging process).
- Heat Evils can evidently injure the Stomach Channel thus causing gingival or periodontal inflammation through eating an overabundance of hot/spicy foods OR by a Liver Yang Rising scenario. It is important to do a thorough intake to target the source of the heat and make an accurate Chinese Medical Differentiation. In these two cases, Bai Hu Tang (for Heat in the Qi Level with the “Four Bigs – Fever, Sweat, Thirst and Pulse” all conditions which readily occur from a acute/aggressive forms of bleeding and bone destruction with periodontal conditions), Huang Lian Jie Du Tang (Clear Heat in the 3 Jiaos – a formula known for clearing pure heat, which can benefit acute periodontal abscesses with severe sensitivity upon clinic evaluation in the dental office or symptoms at home) or dietary modifications would be appropriate. If the heat ensues, the precious Jin Ye and Yin can be depleted (a subsequent Ying Level involvement of Heat), thus requiring yin-supplementation with formulas such as, Liu Wei Di Huang Wan and yin-building acupoints (KD 3, Ren 4, BL 23…) This yin-building formula can especially benefit patients with accompanying heat deficient signs such as, night sweats, hot flashes, irritability and insomnia.
- Kidney deficiency accompanied by Spleen qi and yang deficiency can all be intimately involved in the periodontal disease progression as the aging process occurs and the yin-yang balance exhibits disharmonies. The kidney, as we know for centuries, governs the teeth, where as the blood-containing property of the spleen. The patients with uncontrollable bleeding, despite excellent oral hygiene and very little hard and soft deposits on their teeth, is a classic spleen-based disharmony.
- Helpful supplements for periodontal health include: Vitamin C (1,000 mg/day), Folic Acid (800 mcg/day), Vitamin E (400 IU/day) Echinacea/Tormentil (for gingival inflammation), and the Ayurvedic herb Amla, among many natural remedies available in reducing gingival inflammation and bleeding.
- In terms of the Heat Levels, periodontal disease seems to initiate in the Wei Level in the initial gingivitis stages of gum disease and later progresses into the Qi Level with predominance in its Stomach Heat presentation.
- If the periodontal condition presents as a more generalized than localized condition, the imbalance could be more Kidney Essence based with a Western genetic component, accompanied by weakness in the bone formation, as the teeth are viewed as “extensions of the bone ”.
In conclusion, patients are incredibly fortunate to be able to turn to us, as acupuncturists and herbalists, to quell their periodontal pain, bleeding, and other symptoms. Our ability to address the causation factors, such as Kidney/Spleen/Yin/Yang/Heat imbalances, immune suppression, hormonal imbalances, grinding/clenching and smoking (to name a few) could tremendously benefit the prevention, severity and prevalence of periodontal diseases. Also, as holistic practitioners, aside from our treatments, we need to advise our patients to visit their dentist for regular check-ups, periodontal evaluations, and thorough dental prophylaxis! Our patients need to partake in their oral health with good hygiene practices, healthy dietary habits, and no smoking.
Any questions, please write Dr. Marcy B. Newman, DOM, MPH, RDH – drmarcy@dentalacupuncture.net.